Session 2O

Political Influence and Change

3:30 PM to 5:00 PM | Moderated by John Wilkerson


Show Me the Money: Achieving Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights through Government Budgets
Presenters
  • Alizeh Sadruddin Bhojani, Senior, International Studies, French Mary Gates Scholar
  • Kelsey Jo Bachenberg, Senior, International Studies
  • Youjin Choe, Junior, International Studies, Geography
  • Manmeet Kaur Dhami, Senior, International Studies
  • Julian Wyatt Fellerman, Senior, International Studies
  • Neena Goswamy, Senior, International Studies, Women Studies
  • Thayer Philip (Thayer) Hastings, Senior, International Studies
  • Kristen Caroline Hess, Senior, International Studies
  • Naomi Kristine Joswiak, Senior, Political Science, International Studies
  • Jeffrey Michael Meigs, Senior, International Studies, Spanish
  • Akshika Anjesh Patel, Senior, International Studies, International Studies: Asia
  • Brittney Bree Riley, Senior, International Studies
  • Emilia Maria (Emilis) Sternberg, Senior, International Studies, Swedish
  • Sarah Kosnoff, Senior, International Studies
  • Elisa June Waidelich, Senior, International Studies
Mentor
  • Sanjeev Khagram,
Session
  • 3:30 PM to 5:00 PM

Show Me the Money: Achieving Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights through Government Budgetsclose

 Economic, social, and cultural rights (also known as second generation rights) are often ignored in favor of civil and political rights because they are positive rights that require action from a government. These rights are integral to humanity because they focus on basic human needs such as the right to shelter, food security, and health. Although the international community presented the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights, many of the terms and obligations upon States remain ambiguous. This Task Force focused on elaborating the definitions and possibilites of implementation regarding three specific obligations for countries outlined in Article 2 of the Covenant: to utilize the maximum of their available resources to fulfill the obligations of the Covenant, to progressively achieve human rights, and to implement rights without discrimination. Using United Nations documents, court cases, examples of budgetary and spending challenges, and operation manuals for overseas development aid organizations, we provide a framework and recommendations for understanding and implementing these second generation rights. We concluded that the international community must work to clarify a State's obligations under Article 2, especially concerning budgetary allocations for rights. Furthermore, the international community must regulate the methods of intervention used by overseas development aid organizations in order to ensure their commitment to human rights. 


NGOs and Public Advocacy
Presenters
  • Anna Jensen (Anna) Bohm, Senior, Political Science, Communication
  • Binh Y. (Binh) Vong, Junior, Pre-Social Sciences
Mentors
  • Lance Bennett,
  • Sabine Lang,
Session
  • 3:30 PM to 5:00 PM

NGOs and Public Advocacyclose

How do NGOs in the European Union mobilize constituents and engage publics? Do organizations that operate on the transnational level of governance in Brussels do more or less outreach than NGOs that are rooted in national and subnational civil societies? The research we present here is part of a larger comparative project of EU based and member-state based advocacy in the UK, Germany, and Sweden. We will focus on three policy arenas in the UK: Fair Trade/Economic justice; Climate Change; and gender equality; but for the purpose of this presentation we will only present in one policy arena. A key concept we work with is NGOization, analyzing how professionalization and institutionalization impact public voice. We investigate this subject matter through comparing and contrasting differences in engagement of high-level (policy based) and mid-level (campaign based) organizations. We've generated networks of organizations and ranked the member NGO's according to their external interaction and information exchange with one another. Member organizations receive an inlink rank according to their level of interaction that allow us to understand the location of organizations within the configuration of the member network, and identify the characteristics of outreach according to organizational rank. Since campaigns operate as the main artifacts of public engagement, we classify and analyze targets, effectiveness and engagement levels. Our anticipated results are a greater understanding of how the nongovernmental sector mobilizes publics and defines issue advocacy levels of the public sphere in the UK.


Grass without Roots: Foreign Funding and the Underdevelopment of Nicaraguan Civil Society
Presenter
  • Dean M (Dean) Chahim, Senior, Individualized Studies, Civil Engineering Mary Gates Scholar, NASA Space Grant Scholar, Undergraduate Research Conference Travel Awardee
Mentor
  • Aseem Prakash,
Session
  • 3:30 PM to 5:00 PM

Grass without Roots: Foreign Funding and the Underdevelopment of Nicaraguan Civil Societyclose

How does dependence on foreign funding affect the relationship between non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and the communities they intend to represent? Can NGOs serve as downwardly accountable advocates for social change? This study draws on interviews with staff, volunteers, and recipients in a wide range of local NGOs in Nicaragua as well as an extensive analysis of NGO publications, Nicaraguan news media, and the academic literature on NGO accountability, organization, and relationships with the grassroots. We find that dependence on funding strains the ties of NGOs to constituencies and pushes them from long-term advocacy and organizing towards short-term service and ephemeral mobilization. The result is a disproportionately influential NGO sector which leaves little room for traditional grassroots membership organizations. These results necessitate a rethinking of current funding models and the roles of foreign-funded NGOs in building civil society and catalyzing social change to benefit the marginalized.


Abdul Ghaffar Khan and the Khudai Khidmatgaran: Civil Disobedience in the North West Frontier Province, Colonial India (1929-1947)
Presenter
  • Melody Amy (Melody) Chang, Senior, International Studies Mary Gates Scholar
Mentor
  • Anand Yang,
Session
  • 3:30 PM to 5:00 PM

Abdul Ghaffar Khan and the Khudai Khidmatgaran: Civil Disobedience in the North West Frontier Province, Colonial India (1929-1947)close

There is a saying in Khyber Paktunkhwa (formerly known as the North West Frontier Province): "He is not a Pashtun who does not give a blow in return for a pinch." Yet in 1929, a local community leader named Abdul Ghaffar Khan launched a political movement that advocated for non-violent, civil disobedience against British rule. His followers called themselves Khudai Khidmatgaran -- the "Servants of God." In a society that legitimized the use of lethal force to resolve disputes, Abdul Ghaffar Khan and the Khudai Khidmatagaran became a widespread movement among the local population. I use British colonial records, ethnographies, and translated speeches and a memoir to explore possible reasons for the Khudai Khidmatgaran's popularity in the province. Viewing landownership as a political, social, and economic distinguisher of status, I posit that British land reforms in the late 1800s severely undermined the Pashtun communal identity by abolishing the Pashtuns' historic monopoly on landownership. In essence, the colonial authorities invalidated the Pashtun community's worldview. My preliminary research suggests that Abdul Ghaffar Khan's success originated in his ability to articulate a social narrative for the Pashtun community by redefining the set of behaviors that distinguished "Pashtuns" from "non-Pashtuns." Landownership, and its accompanying role in fueling social violence, was no longer a requirement for 'full' membership in the Pashtun identity. In the process of doing so, the Khudai Khidmatgaran and their supporters made the continuous choice to reject violence as an answer to violence, even in the face of harsh colonial repression.


Electoral Spending Shifts in a Post-Citizens United America
Presenter
  • Sean Andrew (Sean) Freeder, Senior, Political Science
Mentor
  • Matt Barreto,
Session
  • 3:30 PM to 5:00 PM

Electoral Spending Shifts in a Post-Citizens United Americaclose

The American media has recently highlighted a variety of developments, such as the rise of the Tea Party and the decision in the Citizens United case, suggesting a significant shift in how elections are and will be held. Reports have suggested these events would not only bolster certain spending groups, but also lead to a deluge of outside money in national races. However, little academic research has been done to determine whether these claims have merit. This project sets out to answer several questions raised by these new developments in American politics. Was there indeed a measurable increase in spending by lobbying groups in the 2010 election? If so, was this increase limited to groups on the conservative side of the partisan spectrum? Has this spending increased more so amongst ideologically-extreme groups, or amongst interest-based groups? Finally, has the rise of ideologically-based groups actually increased the likelihood of victory for politicians who are the recipients of their money? To answer these questions, I will examine campaign finance data from the 2006 and 2010 elections. Donations will be coded into various donor categories, allowing one to see how much money is being spent by each type of group, and how it has changed before or after Citizens United. I will then conduct statistical analysis to assess patterns. I anticipate that PAC spending in recent years has indeed generally increased, that this spending increase has occurred among conservatives more than liberals, and that it has increased chiefly amongst ideological groups. I also anticipate a modest increase in the electoral success of conservative candidates who receive this ideological money. The value of this research will be to apply scientific methodology to popular claims to see whether they are truthful, and to further explore the degree to and ways in which money impacts and influences our democracy.


In Defense of Freely Forbidding: An Analysis of Early Modern Polish Political Theory and Government
Presenter
  • Matthew James Legacki, Senior, Psychology, History
Mentor
  • James Felak, , University of Washington; Department of History
Session
  • 3:30 PM to 5:00 PM

In Defense of Freely Forbidding: An Analysis of Early Modern Polish Political Theory and Governmentclose

The Republic of Two nations was the first of its kind. It was a government that incorporated all three of Aristotle’s forms of good government-democracy, monarchy, and oligarchy-and the first post-Roman Republic that was larger than a city-state. This republic was founded on the principles of equality and liberty. From these principles the nobles created the government which instituted the Liberum Veto, unanimous voting, and the limited power of the executive branch. Eventually because outside influences would pay for the legislation to be dissolved between 1669 and 1764 the Republic fell into a state of anarchy because there was no legislation passed to control the state. When the Republic reformed itself in 1791 creating Europe’s first constitutional government, the Republic’s three powerful neighbors divided the country since it would no longer lend itself to be manipulated. While the Republic was removed from the map of Europe after two-hundred years in 1795, the blame should not be put entirely on the structure of government as many historians  have done. Adam Zaymoski wrote, “The very existence of the Liberum Veto…leads many to conclude that the Poles had parted with their senses”. However, as WÅ‚adysÅ‚aw CzapliÅ„ski pointed out, this is a simplified view and the discussion should be expanded to include not only the Liberum Veto, but also unanimity in the Sejm, and the political theory which was the basis for the government overall. Rather the blame should go to the patronage system that was susceptible to exploitation and the corruption and weakness of the executive office of the country. The Republic was by no means a perfect government, but the government was founded on sound political theory and altered over the course of its life through debate and discussion, but above all else it was created by men who had not lost their senses.


The University of Washington is committed to providing access and accommodation in its services, programs, and activities. To make a request connected to a disability or health condition contact the Office of Undergraduate Research at undergradresearch@uw.edu or the Disability Services Office at least ten days in advance.