Session 1D

Alternative Representations and the Politics of Understanding

1:00 PM to 2:30 PM | Moderated by Crispin Thurlow


Ghettotainment? Problematizing “Touristic Ways of Seeing” in the LA Gang Tours
Presenter
  • Laura Michelle (Laura) Brody, Senior, Sociology, Communication
Mentor
  • Crispin Thurlow, , UW Bothell
Session
  • 1:00 PM to 2:30 PM

Ghettotainment? Problematizing “Touristic Ways of Seeing” in the LA Gang Toursclose

In January 2010, ex-gang member Alfred Lomas started LA Gang Tours to educate the wider public about conditions in downtown Los Angeles and to help reduce gang violence. With a signed safety waiver and a fee of $65, visitors can experience a part of Los Angeles they usually only know from Hollywood movies or sensational TV news reports. LA Gang Tours has met with a mixture of praise and scrutiny from the mainstream media, with public opinion ultimately divided: is this social justice at work or is it simply a voyeuristic form of “ghettotainment?” In addressing this tension, my project focuses on three recurrent themes: (a) the touristic staging of difference and authenticity; (b) class-based and racialized discourses of violence and order; and (c) grassroots community organization and social “upliftment.” My research is framed by Critical Discourse Studies (e.g. Fairclough, 2003; Cameron, 2001) and by Critical Tourism Studies (e.g. Bruner, 2001; Favero, 2005; Urry, 2001). In my analysis I look at a combination of the internal promotional texts from LA Gang Tours, a range of newspaper media reports about the tours, as well as ethnographic insights from a participant observation. Along with most contemporary tourism scholars, Edward Bruner (2001: 896) characterizes tourism as a form of marketing (“selling a product to an audience”) and argues that this experience hinges on the desire of tourists to see what they want; as such, tour sites have to stage performances that do not necessarily reflect political and social realities. This is what Favero (2005) calls the “touristic way of seeing.” The popularity of LA Gang Tours among Middle and Upper Class, largely White tourists (e.g. academics, foreigners and privileged LA locals) reveals the emergence of a troubling geography of class and race inequality developing in conjunction with an otherwise innovative educational project.


Meaning and What It Can Mean To Us
Presenter
  • Jack Hudson (Jack) Clearman, Junior, Psychology
Mentor
  • David Barash,
Session
  • 1:00 PM to 2:30 PM

Meaning and What It Can Mean To Usclose

Since the beginning of thought, man has asked "what is the meaning of life?" Philosophers of all times and practices have contemplated the answer which still puzzles many of us. It appears that it is not a one size fits all question; for one man's garbage may be another man's treasure. In the field of Positive Psychology, there has been a recent surge in happiness research that spans across the discipline. This has led me to take a more in depth look at meaning and how it affects our daily outlook and well being. Scholars have taken the age old question and broken it down into individual aspects, giving us access to discover meaning at any moment we desire. Furthermore, by sampling authors of different backgrounds and approaches, I am developing my own ideas of how valuable creating meaning can be for us. Our genetic and environmental settings create unique perceptions for each second of our lives, and within our thoughts and actions we can mold meaning and purpose to the most grandiose and mundane moments we experience. 


The Ecology of Transformation in the Theater of Eugène Ionesco
Presenter
  • Claire Antonia (Claire) Fox, Senior, Comparative Literature, Comparative History of Ideas Mary Gates Scholar
Mentor
  • Herbert Blau,
Session
  • 1:00 PM to 2:30 PM

The Ecology of Transformation in the Theater of Eugène Ionescoclose

One red eye and one white eye, or one white eye and one red eye. It seems inevitable, in Eugène Ionesco’s anti-play, The Bald Soprano, that after Mr. Donald Martin asks Mrs. Elizabeth Martin an exhaustively inane series of questions that concludes with the mutual realization they both have a daughter named Alice who has one red eye and one white eye, that Mr. and Mrs. Martin have the same daughter, and are married. However, one can still wonder, as did Martin Esslin in his essay on Ionesco’s theater, “is it really as easily comprehensible as all that?” – the answer, of course, being a wavering “probably not.” After the newly re-discovered Martins embrace and fall asleep, Mary, Mr. and Mrs. Smith’s maid, renders Alice’s eye color useless for generating meaning when she confides to the audience that Mr. Martin’s Alice has the opposite red and white eyes to those of Mrs. Martin’s Alice. Mary further articulates that the collapse of all the extraordinary coincidences demonstrates that not only are Mr. and Mrs. Martin not married, but they are not even Donald and Elizabeth, the individuals they assume themselves to be. At this point, the reader has experienced the swift dismantling of a classical dramatic model and is left in a realm where characters and their relationships in space continue to be subverted. The way in which one recognizes this new formulation of space in the text is the result of Ionesco’s meticulous use of language and pacing. The level of immanence the reader achieves at the point of Mary’s eye color-revelation is decisively related to the way he or she experienced the duration and affect of Mr. Martin’s preceding four-page, exhaustive examination of Mrs. Martin – a trend that is pervasive throughout Ionesco’s dramatic work.


Donald Justice and New Formalist Poetry
Presenter
  • Joseph Kenneth (Joseph) Frantz, Senior, English (Creative Writing)
Mentor
  • Brian Reed,
Session
  • 1:00 PM to 2:30 PM

Donald Justice and New Formalist Poetryclose

Since World War Two, free verse has been the dominant mode in English Language poetry. It has not gone without contest, however; in the mid-1980s, the New Formalist movement arose, advocating a return to traditional rhyme and meter. Two of the most influential New Formalist polemicists, Dana Gioia and William Logan, were strongly influenced by the mid-century poet Donald Justice, whom they took to be a guiding figure. Through examination of Gioia’s critical opus Can Poetry Matter? and Logan’s anthology Desperate Measures, the aesthetic standpoints from which these critics approach the works of Justice can be located. These standpoints are expressed in the anthology Certain Solitudes: On the Poetry of Donald Justice (edited by Gioia and Logan). Through close reading of Certain Solitudes and Justice’s poetic corpus, it is found that Gioia and Logan fail to center Justice’s poetic formality on the concept of organic form. While inorganic form takes form as prior to content, organic form takes form and content as inevitably comingling and guiding one another. Justice’s work invariably makes use of organic form. In poems like “Poem” and “American Scenes,” Justice’s choices of line length, rhyme, and meter are closely measured against choices of diction, tone, and imagery. The appreciative criticisms of Gioia and Logan discuss issues of form separately from those of tone, diction, and rhetoric; because of this, their approaches to the poems of Justice misidentify the role played by Justice’s formal considerations.


Cosmopolitanisms and the “Transitional Territories” of Mon Oncle and Giants and Toys
Presenter
  • Mikki Noel Kressbach, Senior, Comparative Literature (Cinema Studies)
Mentor
  • James Tweedie,
Session
  • 1:00 PM to 2:30 PM

Cosmopolitanisms and the “Transitional Territories” of Mon Oncle and Giants and Toysclose

The 1950’s and 60’s saw the crashing of cinematic “New Waves” across the world. These culturally, nationally and formally distinct movements marked a period of reassessment and reflection on the cinematic form and content in the context of critical and historical filmic unrest. As these Waves reshaped their respective national cinemas, the question begs, what about this particular historical moment caused the consecutive and simultaneous rethinking of the cinematic medium? Looking at two waves, the Japanese and French, the exploration of overarching theories of globalization and cosmopolitanism provide key threads for discovering the dispersion of visual and thematic elements spanning national and cultural boarders. Both globalization and cosmopolitanism remain shifting theoretical concepts dependent upon historical and cultural context. Through the exploration of Jacques Tati’s Mon Oncle (1958) and Yasuzo Masumura’s Giants and Toys (1958), films that both serve as precursors to their respective New Waves in 1960, the debate surrounding conceptions of global culture will be contextualized in the disjunctive relationship between global and local discussions of cultural identity. By examining these transitional cultural spaces and subsequent encounters with cultural overlap, we will directly confront working definitions of globalization, cosmopolitanism and global culture. Here, the central threat becomes the homogenization of culture at the hands of capitalist influences. However, the critical (and historical) positionality of both films denies the logical projection of homogenized culture. Instead, they open up cinema as a site to rethink the inevitability of a totalizing globalized culture and examine the complex relationship between national and global identities as an active agent in the process of filmic transformation.


Fabricating Mr. Ethnic-Authentic In Toni Cade Bambara’s “Mississippi Ham Rider”
Presenter
  • Allison Renee Greer (Allison) Ross, Sophomore, Classics, American Ethnic Studies Mary Gates Scholar
Mentor
  • Sonnet Retman,
Session
  • 1:00 PM to 2:30 PM

Fabricating Mr. Ethnic-Authentic In Toni Cade Bambara’s “Mississippi Ham Rider”close

In her short story “Mississippi Ham Rider” (1964), African American author and political activist Toni Cade Bambara presents a fictional account of the exploitation of African American bluesmen by the white Northern record industry in early to mid-twentieth century America. Though little scholarship exists about this work, I argue that “Mississippi Ham Rider” is a seminal and relevant text which juxtaposes the search for an individual’s ethnic identity with mass-marketed constructions of racial "authenticity.” Bambara challenges conventional representations of the “ethnic-authentic” by deliberately confounding the racial, gender, class, and regional stereotypes that define the central figures in her narrative. Employing an intersectional approach in my literary analysis, I explore the significance of each protagonist’s multi-dimensional character traits. The colloquial descriptions of Mississippi Ham Rider, an old-time bluesman, as both “Mr. Ethnic-Authentic” and a “salty stud”; Neil McLoughlin, a white Northern record producer as “Mr. Somebody”; and Inez Williams, a light-skinned African American narrator, as “high yaller,” symbolically capture the ironic and iconic personas of bluesmen and the industry promoters who fabricate their legacies. By exploring the complexity of race, gender, class and regional identity within “Mississippi Ham Rider," Bambara problematizes the relationship between ethnic identity and the commoditization of racial “authenticity” of African Americans. Offering readers a story that is both reflective and prescient, Bambara provides a framework to contextualize this commercialization in historical and modern musical genres, such as string band folk, hip-hop and urban rap. By politicizing this search for the “ethnic-authentic,” Toni Cade Bambara exposes how disingenuous the genuine “authentic” might be.


Visual Violence: Deconstructing the Romani Myth in Three Films of Tony Gatlif
Presenter
  • Brandon Paul (Brandon) Weaver, Senior, Comparative History of Ideas, English
Mentor
  • Vera Sokolova,
Session
  • 1:00 PM to 2:30 PM

Visual Violence: Deconstructing the Romani Myth in Three Films of Tony Gatlifclose

It is estimated that up to 1.5 million Roma (commonly referred to as gypsies), were massacred in the Holocaust and yet, this fact or any other fact concerning the Roma is rarely mentioned in any account of the Holocaust. The Roma (commonly referred to as gypsies) have one of the most overdetermined identities in the world and one of the most underrepresented. Largely considered a degenerate, illiterate race, governments across Europe have persecuted the Roma for nearly a millennium. But. They are neither degenerate nor illiterate. My research looks at the cultural image of the gypsy in relation to the historical (and contemporary) violence committed against the Roma. The way people speak and write about the Roma as a minority has concrete effects on the ways in which the majority act towards them. As culturally motivated violence, if one is to find a way to subvert these prejudices, it becomes important to examine cultural products of the Roma themselves (or those sympathetic to the Roma). For this reason, I analyze the films of Tony Gatlif, an Algerian born French Romani. His films subvert the mythic expectations about the Roma by critiquing the notion of a stable identitiy in favor of a dynamic and shifting one. I argue that Gatlif’s films adapt Deuleuze and Guattari’s arguments in their book on Kafka concerning minorities writing in major languages to the visual realm. I turn then to Gayatri Spivak’s essay “Can the Subaltern Speak?” to consider the importance of the visual in post-colonial identity. Gatlif’s films consistently cross national and linguistic borders, imagining a different way for people to interact across these boundaries. They not only present a sympathetic picture of the Romani contrary popular rendering, but they promote inclusive engagement with those who may be ‘other.’


The University of Washington is committed to providing access and accommodation in its services, programs, and activities. To make a request connected to a disability or health condition contact the Office of Undergraduate Research at undergradresearch@uw.edu or the Disability Services Office at least ten days in advance.